MEETING OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS OF
PLAZA EAST ASSOCIATION
June 18, 2008
Pursuant to notice the Board of
Directors of Plaza East Association, Inc. met in regular session on
Wednesday June 18, 2008 at 7:30 P.M. in the Recreation Room, 4300
N. Ocean Blvd., Fort Lauderdale, FL 33308. Directors in attendance
were James Brady, Donald Galczak, Rafick Henein, Richard Madey,
Jose Namis, Jeanne Poore, DiAnne Shumard, Tim Smith, Alex Soufrine
and John Toklucu. Also in attendance was Property Manager David
Beswick. Robert Buehler was not present. Mr. Smith chaired the
meeting and Mr. Beswick recorded the proceedings. The meeting was
called to order at 7:40 P.M. As there is no Secretary, Mr. Beswick
called the Roll.
Thereafter, upon motion by Mr.
Brady, seconded by Mr. Toklucu, it was unanimously voted to approve
the Minutes of the Special Meeting of May 14, 2008.
Thereafter, upon motion by Mr.
Madey, seconded by Mr. Brady, it was unanimously voted to amend the
Minutes of the April 30, 2008 Regular Meeting, and upon motion by
Mr. Madey, seconded by Mr. Namis, it was unanimously voted to
approve the amended minutes of the April 30, 2008 Regular
Meeting.
Thereafter, Mr. Namis addressed the
Board of Directors and the assembled homeowners regarding some
rumors that have been circulating through the Plaza East
Community. A copy of that address is attached to, and made a
part of these Minutes.
Thereafter, Mr. Madey gave the
Treasurer’s Report for the Month of April, a copy of which is
attached to and made a part of these minutes. The expenditures for
April were less than one twelfth of the Annual Budget but payroll
is still over budget. The total maintenance in arrears for April is
$44,107 from 6 units.
Thereafter, Mr. Madey reported that
the tabled March Treasurers Report contained correct figures for
expenditures from the Building & Mechanical Reserve and the
Hurricane Wilma S/A Account and made a motion that the expenditures
from the reserve be approved. The motion was seconded by Mrs. Poore
and was approved unanimously.
Thereafter, Mr. Madey made a motion
that the Board approve the April expenditures from the Building
& Mechanical and Concrete Reserve and from the Hurricane
Shutters and Hurricane Wilma S/A’s. The motion was seconded
by Mr. Toklucu and unanimously approved by the Board.
Thereafter, upon motion by Mr.
Madey, seconded by Mr. Soufrine, it was unanimously voted to apply
a late fee equal to the greater of 10% or $5.00 to work orders that
are unpaid for 30 days or more, and that the Manager not approve
any new work orders for those units in arrears.
Thereafter, Mr. Madey moved that any
owner with an unpaid parking invoice be given a warning that the
car will be towed away and the parking permit will be revoked
unless the owner removes the delinquency in 72 hours. The motion
was seconded by Mr. Brady. After discussion, Mr. Toklucu moved to
table the matter until the September meeting, which was seconded by
Ms. Shumard, and unanimously approved.
Thereafter, upon motion by Mr.
Madey, seconded by Mr. Toklucu, that owners holding cabana
spaces who are more than 30 days in arrears must relinquish their
cabana reservation, the matter was discussed, and upon motion by
Ms. Shumard, seconded by Mr. Henein, it was unanimously voted to
table the original motion and to direct the Rules Committee to
study these matters and report back to the Board of Directors in
September of 2008.
Thereafter, Mr. Madey introduced a
motion that would transfer funds from the Special
Assessment-Hurricane Shutter Account to a new account that would be
known as Common Area Protection. After discussion, it was decided
to table this matter as it was not properly noticed on the agenda
and also for a legal opinion from the Association
Attorney.
Thereafter, upon motion by Mr.
Madey, seconded by Mr. Toklucu, it was unanimously voted to reduce
the Application for ownership fee from $150 to $100 to be in
compliance with Florida Statutes.
Thereafter, upon motion by Mr. Madey
that each new homeowner coming into Plaza East be required to pay 2
quarterly maintenance payments in advance as a security deposit and
after the new owner makes four timely, regular maintenance payments
and is not in arrears on any other assessments, the security
deposit will be returned at the rate of 25% with each timely
maintenance payment thereafter. Discussion was held and the motion
was withdrawn.
PRESIDENTS REPORT
Thereafter, President Smith reported
that Mr. Ismet Baker has resigned as Chairman of the 2009 Budget
Committee, and thanked Mr. Baker for his service.
Thereafter, President Smith reported
on an EEOC complaint filed against Plaza East by a former employee,
Greg Gerson, who was terminated from his position as a Security
Officer after committing an act of insubordination and is now
claiming that he was not paid for a huge amount of hours, which is
an obvious attempt to extort money that he is not entitled to
receive. After discussion, it was decided to proceed with the
defense of the Association through the Attorney.
Thereafter, President Smith spoke on
a survey conducted over the past six months to determine the amount
of pedestrian traffic passing through lobby 2 and lobby 3 in during
the second shift. There was discussion regarding the cost savings
generated, and the services provided by Security. Upon motion
by Mr. Soufrine, seconded by Mr. Brady is was unanimously voted to
close Lobby 2 and lobby 3 at 9:00 P.M. on each night between July
1, 2008 and November 1, 2008 and to evaluate the results of that
program by the October 29, 2008 Board Meeting. Also, a letter will
be prepared and sent to the Owners explaining the
program.
Thereafter, President Smith reported
on the matter of the Manager’s Contract. President Smith
outlined the results of the performance review conducted and
recommendations made. After discussion, and upon motion by Mr.
Brady, seconded by Mr. Henein, it was voted to offer the Manager a
1-year contract with a 5% increase in pay. Voting in favor were Mr.
Brady, Mr. Galczak, Mr. Henein, Mr. Madey, Ms. Shumard, President
Smith, Mr. Soufrine and Mr. Toklucu. Voting in opposition were Mrs.
Poore and Mr. Namis.
Thereafter, Mr. Beswick delivered
the Manager’s Report for June of 2008, which is attached to,
and made a part of these minutes. Highlights: Armstrong Consulting
will perform a Reserve Study; All-American has begun installing
windows in the Rec Room; bids were sought to provide hurricane
protection for common areas; a reimbursement check is on the way to
cover the loss from the employee theft; the exterior lighting has
been repaired; proposals for engineering oversight on the garage
are coming in; the trees have been hurricane cut.
Committee Reports
Thereafter, President Smith reported
on an organizational meeting he held with the Committee
Chairs
Old Business
Thereafter, the matter of relocating
the stairway passage to the Exercise Room was discussed. A motion
was made by Mrs. Poore, seconded by Mr. Soufrine to continue with
the installation of a stairway from the hall to the Exercise Room
floor. Voting in favor were Mr. Henein, Ms. Shumard, President
Smith, Mr. Soufrine and Mr. Toklucu. Voting in opposition were Mr.
Brady, Mr. Galczak, Mr. Madey, Mr. Namis and Mrs. Poore.. Due to a
tie, this became a non-vote.
Thereafter, Mr. Henein gave a report
on the progress of the Recreation Room project.
Thereafter, the matter of shutters
and common area windows was discussed. Mr. Soufrine presented a
motion, seconded by Mr. Toklucu, to enter into a letter of intent,
followed by a contract, consistent with the letter dated June
16, 2008, with All-American One Source Windows & Doors to
provide hurricane impact resistant windows for all the common areas
of the building, after completion and inspection of the Recreation
Room windows. A motion was made by Mr. Soufrine, seconded by Mr.
Toklucu, that upon completion and approval of the Recreation Room
window installation, to proceed with a letter of intent to
All-American One Source to proceed with the purchase and
installation of hurricane impact windows in the common areas of
Plaza East. Voting in favor of the motion were Mr. Brady, Mr.
Henein Mr. Namis, Mrs. Poore, Ms. Shumard, President Smith, Mr.
Soufrine and Mr. Toklucu. Voting in opposition were Mr. Galczak and
Mr. Madey.
Thereafter, Mr. Madey moved to
accept the revised Purchasing Policy discussed at the May and June
meetings. The motion was seconded by Mrs. Poore and approved
unanimously.
New Business
Thereafter, the Board entertained a
complaint about the President and the Property Manager from a
resident.
During the above discussion Mr.
Brady and Mr. Namis departed the meeting.
Thereafter, a discussion took place
regarding the sale of Unit 14C and the money owed to Plaza
East.
Thereafter, Mr. Henein readdressed
the matter of the stairway passage between the hall and the
Exercise Room. Mr. Henein moved that the plan for the stairs
proceed as previously approved, seconded by Mr. Toklucu. Voting in
favor of the motion were Mr. Henein, Ms. Shumard, President Smith,
Mr. Soufrine and Mr. Toklucu. Voting in opposition were Mr.
Galczak, Mr. Madey and Mrs. Poore.
Thereafter, the meeting was
adjourned at 10:35 P.M.
Respectfully Submitted,