MEETING
OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS OF PLAZA EAST ASSOCIATION
FEBRUARY 27, 2008
Pursuant to notice the Board of Directors of
Plaza East Association, Inc. met in regular session on Wednesday
February 27, 2008 at 7:00 P.M. in the Recreation Room, 4300 N.
Ocean Blvd., Fort Lauderdale, FL 33308. Directors in attendance
were James Brady, Robert Buehler, Donald Galczak, Richard Madey,
Jeanne Poore, Armando Namis, Dianne Shumard, Tim Smith, Alex
Soufrine and John Toklucu. Rafick Henein and Property Manager David
Beswick were not present. Also present was Administrative
Assistant, Ms. Ayasha Agarrat. Mr. Smith chaired the meeting and
Ms. Agarrat recorded the proceedings. The meeting was called to
order at 7:16 P.M. and began with the Pledge of Allegiance to the
Flag followed by roll call.
Thereafter, on a motion by Mr. Brady and second by Mr. Soufrine,
the minutes of the Board Meeting of January 30, 2008 were approved
as amended.
Thereafter, on a motion by Mr. Brady, seconded by Ms. Shumard, it
was unanimously voted to table approval of the Minutes of the
December 19, 2007 Board Meeting.
Thereafter, on a motion by Mr. Buehler, seconded by Mr. Madey, it
was unanimously voted that the recordings made of the Board Meeting
proceedings be properly maintained and safeguarded until such time
as the minutes were approved by the Board of Directors at a
subsequent meeting. As a part of this action, the Board discussed
the matters of the possibility of broadcasting Board Meetings on
the community channel; proper decorum and courtesy to aid in
recording of the proceedings; safeguarding the records of e-mail
communication between Board Members and proper backup for Office
computers. President Smith indicated that he would direct the
Property Manager to investigate the equipment necessary to perform
some of these tasks.
Thereafter, on a motion by Mr. Madey, seconded by Mr. Toklucu, it
was unanimously voted to make the Property Manager responsible for
maintaining the aforementioned records.
Thereafter, the Treasurers Report was made by Mr. Madey. The
Treasurers Report is attached to and made a part of these Minutes.
Upon motion by Mr. Madey, seconded by Mr. Galczak, it was voted to
approve the expenditures from the Reserve Accounts Mr. Buehler, Mr.
Galczak, Mr. Madey, Mrs. Poore. Ms. Shumard, President Smith, Mr.
Soufrine and Mr. Toklucu voted in the affirmative while Mr. Brady
and Dr. Namis voted against approval. Thereafter, upon motion by
Mr. Brady, it was unanimously voted to table the approval of the
expenditures from the Special Assessment funds until the next Board
Meeting for the purposes of explaining the expenditures in depth.
Thereafter, after a discussion regarding the fee charged to Plaza
East by the bank for receiving payments on checks drawn from
foreign banks, upon motion by Mr. Madey, seconded by Mr. Brady, it
was unanimously voted to add the fee charged by the bank to the
account of the owner submitting the payment.
Thereafter, President Smith presented the President’s Report.
The sign-up sheets for volunteers who wish to serve on a committee
will remain available for one more week for those who wish to
volunteer but have not yet done so. The President will appoint
interim chairs of committees and upon their first meeting, the
committees will each elect their permanent chairs. Committee chairs
will then appoint a secretary for their committees to prepare
committee meeting minutes. Each committee will have at least one
but not more than five board members. Thereafter, President Smith
appointed Mrs. Helen baker as Chair of the Screening Committee as
there is a screening scheduled for March 4, 2008. Mr. Jerry Marcial
and Mrs. Florence Berliner have also volunteered to serve on the
Screening Committee. Thereafter, President Smith announced that it
was do time to perform a reserve study and that the Property
Manager would be asked to arrange for this study to be done.
Thereafter, the Board had a discussion regarding the current and
proposed use of cabanas/cabana spaces. Thereafter, President Smith
spoke about the progress made on adopting Purchasing Policies &
Procedures, and that it was hoped that something would be presented
at the next Board Meeting.
Thereafter, upon motion by Mrs. Poore, seconded by Mr. Madey, the
proposal to have a special board meeting on the second Wednesday of
each month was defeated with President Smith, Mr. Brady, Mr.
Galczak, Mr. Soufrine, Ms. Shumard and Mr. Toklucu and
in opposition and Mr. Buehler, Mr.
Madey, Mr. Namis and Mrs. Poore in favor of the
motion.
Thereafter, the matter of the mandate by the State of Florida Dept.
of Environmental Protection that Plaza East stop using the outfall
as a part of the A/C cooling system was discussed. It was announced
that the D.E.P had been contacted by the Association Attorney
regarding issues of Force Majure and were not willing to change the
language of the decree but were willing to give Plaza east a 60 day
extension on the completion date bringing it to March 1, 2009. The
discussion also concerned the projected cost and anticipated
location of the proposed cooling tower, and also included having
the project engineer attend the next Board Meeting.
Thereafter, the matter of the erection of a security fence on the
border with Plaza South was discussed.
Thereafter, the matter of the noise generated by the A/C chiller
located on the South side of Fountainhead Condominium was discussed
and President Smith announced that the Property Manager would be
directed this summer to solicit proposals from three sound &
vibration engineering companies to perform a study on this noise
problem and make recommendations. Thereafter, President Smith
announced that there was nothing new to report on the Flamingo
Avenue drainage situation. Thereafter, it was announced by
President Smith that a letter of resignation from the Entertainment
Committee was received from Ira Seltzer and that the Property
Manager was directed to prepare a letter of thanks to Mr. Seltzer
for his services under the President’s signature. It was so
moved by Mr. Brady and seconded by Mr. Soufrine to prepare this
letter and the measure passed unanimously.
Thereafter, the matter of the request for appearance of Plaza East
Board Members and Attorney at a public hearing held by State
Representative Julio Robaina and the Select Committee on
Condominium and Homeowner Association Governance was discussed.
President Smith reported on the voluntary invitations to attend
public hearings in Pembroke Pines, South Miami Beach, Orlando and
also to answer a Subpoena Duces Tecum to provide documents and
testimony at a public hearing in Tampa.
Thereafter, Mrs. Marion Packard reported that T-Volt Electric was
employed to install some additional spotlight fixtures in the West
side parking lots for reasons of residents’ safety, and also
to correct some electric defaults in the lighting system located in
the grassy areas on the patio deck that could have resulted in
severe injury had they not been corrected.
Thereafter, Mr. Brady expressed the thanks of the entire Board of
Directors to the Committee heads and their committee members for
the vast amount of work they perform on the Community’s
behalf.
Thereafter, President Smith read the Manager’s Report for
March, 2008, which is attached to and made a part of these minutes.
Items covered included the replacement of the A/C coolant well
pump; the installation of the Key Fob entry system has been
completed and is now being debugged. Fobs will be issued soon; the
expiration date of the 145 fire hoses has passed and the cost to
replace is $15,065.60 and requires Board approval. Thereafter, upon
motion by Mr. Brady, seconded by Mr. Toklucu it was unanimously
vote to proceed with a contract to replace the fire hoses; on
February 26, 2008 requests for proposals were sent to six different
concrete repair companies based on unit pricing. President Smith
also touched on the deterioration of the catwalk knee walls; a
letter was prepared to go out to the homeowners advising them on
the situation with the trash chutes and that recycling will have to
be brought to the lower garage. Board approval is required for this
letter. There after, on a motion by Mr. Buehler, seconded by Mr.
Soufrine it was unanimously voted to approve the letter to the
homeowners. Thereafter Mr. Brady offered, with Board approval, to
take up this issue with the State Fire Marshall. Upon motion by
President Smith, seconded by Mr. Galczak, it was unanimously voted
to proceed. Thereafter, the matter of proceeding with the proposal
to correct the electrical overheating problems was tabled until the
next meeting; the Plaza East cooling tower noise issue was
discussed; the Maintenance Staff will be painting the walls and
floors of the catwalk entrances beginning March 3, 2008; Action
Accessibility was out on February 22, 2008 to perform the
contracted repairs on the pool lift; Edwards Service contacted the
office on February 21, 2008 and provided the information that they
would be doing the final inspection beginning Monday February 25,
2008.
Thereafter, President Smith announced that the employee’s
time clock had been replaced with an Ethernet system to make
payroll reporting more efficient, and also that the
Association’s filing system will require some additional work
to make retrieval easier. The matter of materials required for
approval of ownership was discussed.
Thereafter, the matter of security cameras in the Management Office
and the Mail Room was discussed along with the possibility of
installing additional cameras in bathrooms, saunas and store rooms.
Thereafter, upon motion by Mr. Toklucu, seconded by Ms. Shumard is
was voted six Members to four to proceed with the repair of the
camera equipment in the Management Offices and Mail Room. Voting in
favor were Ms. Shumard, Mr. Smith, Mr. Soufrine, Mr. Brady and Mr.
X. Voting in opposition to the motion were Mr. Buehler, Dr. Namis,
Ms. Poore, Mr. X.
Correspondence
Thereafter, based on a letter from Mr. Richard Mayhill, the matter
of a complaint from the relative of a unit owner regarding a fine
levied by the City of Ft. Lauderdale against Plaza East as the
result of a false fire alarm caused by the failure to cover a smoke
detector in the unit while work was being conducted was discussed.
Upon motion by Mr. X, seconded by Mr. Buehler, it was voted to not
assess the unit owner for the cost of the fine. Voting in favor
were President Smith, Mr. Buehler, Mr. Madey, Dr. Namis, Mrs.
Poore, Ms. Shumard, Mr. Soufrine and Mr. Toklucu and Mr. Galczak
voted in opposition.
Thereafter, based on a letter from Mrs. Florence Berliner of Unit
9H, a discussion of the placement of an air conditioning cooling
tower on the Plaza East roof over the GH Stack was discussed.
President Smith announced that Engineer Chris Covalt of DeRose
Engineering would be asked to attend the next meeting and answer
questions in this regard.
Thereafter, President Smith spoke regarding a letter from Mr.
Harold Wechsler of Unit 12L, questioning the appropriation of Wilma
Special Assessment money to remove and replace brick pavers in the
planting area at the front of Plaza East. President Smith stated
that it was his opinion that the work should be paid out of regular
maintenance funds. The conversation then encompassed the matter of
fountains in the same area.
Thereafter, President Smith announced the receipt of a series of
letters from Mr. Harold Wechsler of Unit 12L which constituted a
challenge of the recent election of Board Members. A discussion of
election procedures took place and recommendations were made.
New
Business
Thereafter, Dr. Namis commented on the need for a business plan for
Plaza East.
Thereafter, President Smith commented on the importance of
committees and the Committee Head Meeting held on the Tuesday
evening, 1 week prior to each Board Meeting.
Thereafter, Mr. Buehler announced that he would be holding a
monthly owners’ forum in the Recreation Room.
Thereafter, the meeting was adjourned at 11:04 P.M.
Respectfully Submitted,