PLAZA EAST ASSOCIATION
MINUTES OF A SSPECIAL MEETING OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS
AUGUST 24, 2005
1. CALL TO ORDER AND PLEDGE OF
ALLEGIANCE
President Terry Marcum
called to order a duly constituted special meeting of the Plaza
East Board of Directors on Wednesday, August 24, 2005 at 7:30 PM in
the Recreation Room. President Marcum led the Pledge of
Allegiance.
2.
ROLL CALL
Present:
Ismet
Baker, Charlotte Gazzana, Richard Loarie, Jerry Marcial, Terry
Marcum, Alan Pell, DiAnne Shumard , Tim Smith and John Toklucu.
Also present was Richard Madey, Secretary.
Absent:
James
Brady
Quorum?
Yes
3.
LOBBY COMMITTEE PRESENTATIONS
Eugenie Moriconi,
Chair, Lobby Refurbishment Committee, introduced the following
representatives from each of three Interior Design Firms, who
presented conceptual design proposals for refurbishing Lobby
Two:
3.1 Fredo Valladares,
Design Nuovo, Weston
3.2 Steve Frelish, ASID Affilate
3.3 Cesar Conde, Casa Conde, Ft. Lauderdale
For the benefit of unit owners who were unable to attend the
meeting, Eugenie Moriconi managed to have these presentations
appear on the Plaza East web page.
www.Plazaeast.info
4.
QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS
Questions were asked
about furniture placement, lighting plan, elevator cabs, and time
and costs to complete work. The following is not an all inclusive
list of questions and answers.
4.1
Questions to Fredo Valladares
Q1. How access ceiling for maintenance?
A1. Floating grid system is totally removable.
Q2. Will there be a problem with the heat emitted by 9 halogen
lights, which are on 24 hours per day.
A2. Xenon lights are cooler and last longer.
Q3. What provision is made for transporting large pieces in
elevators?
A3. Corner pieces in ceiling are removable to allow more
space.
Q4. Has the ceiling lighting plan been reviewed by an
electrician?
A4. Not yet, as this is only a conceptual design proposal. An
allowance is needed for unforeseen elements. Electrical work must
be up to code.
Q5. What is the purpose of the floating ceiling?
A5. It provides a visual definition of an area. (Recessed lighting
above grids will be placed so grids do not block light).
Q6. What is your estimate of time to do three lobbies?
A6.Three years was discussed. The time depends on how fast funding
is arranged.
Q7. How many customized pieces in your plan?
A7. Furniture, ceiling, light fixtures are not customized. Will get
three bids for customized items.
Q8. What is your estimated cost?
A8. I submitted an estimated price per square foot. (which is $
9l). This figure does not include electrical, mechanical,
etc.
Q9. Will the lobbies flow into each other?
A9. Yes. Fabrics will change slightly
4.2
Questions to Steve Frelich
Q1. How is damage minimized to elevators during moves?
A1. There is no material that won’t be damaged. Put in pads
and supervise.
Q2. What would be around elevators?
A.
Wood
Q3. Where are you locating benches?
A3. By the front door, and by the old front desk
Q4. What is your estimate of time to do three lobbies?
A4. Three months
Q5. What would you do about dents to stainless steel panels in
elevators?
A5. Use wood panels
Q6. How would you introduce color?
A6. Bring in color through pillows, etc; and plants. Use light
blue/green to pickup sky.
Q7. How much is allowed for electrical work for lighting?
A7. The amount is estimated at present. It is necessary to budget
for unanticipated problems.
Q8. What is your fee structure?
A8. I charge a design
fee for my time and expertise. All items are purchased at net cost
and billed directly to Plaza East.
4.3
Questions to Cesar Condo
Q1. What is your estimate of time to do three lobbies?
A1. After obtaining permit, about six months for lobby 2 and eight
to nine months for all three lobbies.
Q2. What is your fee structure?
A2. All purchased items are billed at cost plus 30%. If I need to
meet with a contractor, my hourly fee is $150.
5.
BOARD APPROVAL AND SELECTION OF WINNING DESIGN FIRM FOR
COMPLETION OF THE FINAL LOBBIES DESIGN
Marcum:
Reconvened
meeting at 9:35 pm after a ten minute break. Thanked lobby
Committee for all the good work done to get to this point. Asked
for comments.
Mariconi: Cesar Condo is the most
expensive, but the most thorough. Noted that
grout can
be changed on the floor. Condo proposed drapery panels. Some unit
owners prefer window treatments; others do
not.
Marcum:
Cost
breakdowns
$/sf Total cost(not included Sales) area(sq.ft)
1. Fredo Valladaras 91 955,500 10,500
2. Steve Frelich 59(a) 1,000,000(?) 17,000(a)
3. Cesar Condo 113 (b) 1,186,500 10,500
____________
(a) Includes recreation
room
(b) Purchased items are billed at cost plus 30%. If Cesar meets
with contractors, he bills his time at $150 per
hour.
Marcum:
Association
will control costs
Loarie:
Pick the
person whom we feel most confident in doing job. Fredo and Cesar
teams had a vision; Frelich did not.
Stan
Rotherberg:
Poll Lobby
Committee members.
Results
of Poll: Cesar (5), Fredo (4),
Steve (2)
Loarie:
Cesar’s cost plus
30% for each purchased item should include responsibility for
receiving, checking and overseeing item purchased.
Smith:
We should
rank two designers and proceed subject to negotiating a
satisfactory contract.
Moriconi: All designers are
responsive to changes. Fredo’s work is a combination of Fredo
and Ken Campbell (who was rejected by the Committee).
Toklucu:
Do you
think that Cesar would be willing to work with the price a
little?
Moriconi:
Yes, I
think we can obtain a satisfactory contract with Cesar.
Selzer:
Cesar
responded quickly. Fredo was not well prepared.
Baker:
What do you
pay for a designer?
Pell:
Liked
Frelich’s statement that all billings come to Plaza
East.
Marcum:
Call for a
vote. Rank number 1 and number 2.
Marcial:
My taste is
for Fredo, but my vote is for Cesar because he works best with the
Committee.
Gazzana:
Cesar;
Frelich
Smith:
Cesar;
Fredo
Loarie:
Cesar; no
second choice
Shumard:
Frelich;
Fredo
Marcum:
Cesar,
Fredo
Pell:
Frelich;
Fredo
Toklucu:
Cesar; Fredo
Baker:
Cesar;
Fredo
MOTION:
Toklucu
(Loarie) moved (seconded) to contract with Cesar Condo to proceed
with the design. Passed unanimously.
Note:
Meeting was
for selection of design firm only. Final contract and final design
cost will sent out to Association for 75%
approval.
5.
ADJOURMENT
Meeting was adjourned
at 10:30 pm.
Respectfully Submitted
Richard Madey
Secretary