PLAZA EAST ASSOCIATION
MINUTES OF MEETING OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS
December 6, 2006
Mr.
Richard Loarie, President called to order a duly constituted
meeting of the Plaza East Board of Directors
on Wednesday December 6, 2006 at 7:35 p.m. in the Recreation
Room.
Present were: Ismet Baker, Allen Pell, Richard Loarie, Charles
Packard, Terry Marcum, DiAnne
Shumard, Tim Smith, and John Toklucu. Also present Mike Morgan,
Manager. A quorum was
established.
Absent: Alex Soufrine, James Brady, Rafick Henein, and Helene
Pasternak, Secretary.
MINUTES
APPROVAL
Richard Loarie
made a motion, seconded by Charles Packard to approve the Regular
Board Meeting minutes
of October 25, 2006 and Special Board Meeting minutes of November
15, 2006. All approved Aye.
TREASURER’S
REPORT
Ismet Baker gave
the Treasurer’s report. A motion was made by Richard Loarie,
seconded by Ismet Baker to
approve the transfer of $6,846.98 from Reserves to the Operating
Fund for (1) UpBeat Inc. for Bellmans
carts, (2) Murphy Construction for Mechanical room unit doors, and
(3) Howard Miller inspection of RTI
work. All voted Aye
PRESIDENT’S
REPORT
Agenda Posted:
Monday December 4, 2006 - Commencement 7:30 PM Recreation
Rm
o
Special Meeting for Wednesday
December 20, 2006, will be charred by Charles Packard, with
Ismet
Baker as Co-Chair. Ismet is Budget Chair. Meeting is to receive
Owner proxies on (A) 2007 Partial
Reserves, or (B) Full Reserves.
o Next Regular Monthly Board meeting Wednesday
January 10, 2006,
o Key Fob Secure Entry Proposal for 24/7 keyed
entry will arranged for a presentation by GE EST at
our Board Meeting on January 10, 2006. Manager Morgan to coordinate
with GE EST group. This
presentation will be the first order of
business.
o Proposal for full funding of Recreation room
refurbishing by Ismet Baker will be developed with
budget from Interior Committee. Tim Smith will coordinate with
Interior Committee.
o Proposal for Contractor fee during Unit Owner
Remodeling, for elevator and lobby (cleaning &
repair), was motioned by Charles Packard seconded by Tim Smith.
Motion for $500 owner deposit
to offset elevator and lobby damage/cleaning costs. $500 Fee paid
prior to remodeling
commencement, not limited to elevators, foyer, or lobby common
areas. Tim Smith asked for tighter
control over Contractor and Sub-Contractor movement through Plaza
East of materials and
demolition rubbish. Manager Morgan and staff will monitor all
contractor movements. Prior to
remodeling, forms are to be filled out and presented to Manager.
Fee will go into effect immediately.
o Motion by President Loarie made for date of
Annual Meeting on Wednesday February 21, 2007 at
10 AM in our Recreation room, seconded by Charles Packard. All
voted Aye.
o Shutter track Head detail requirement above
windows (as per owner approval to install common area
shutters) will be coordinated through Terry Tavist (Shutter Tech
Systems) engineer and included
with details in Permit set drawings as an addendum. Meeting with
Shutter Tech Engineer, President,
and Manager is to be Scheduled for Monday December 11, or Tuesday
December 12. Plaza East’s
original design did not include provision for common area shutters.
Shutters added on the East wall
of the Recreation Room were not permitted or
installed correctly, as they were attached to the
suspended Stucco, without proper support for dead loads or wind
loads. During or before Hurricane
Wilma wind loads moved Lobby One’s suspended stucco ceiling
adjacent to our window wall head,
causing a gap between Suspended Stucco and window. Air freely moves
up into our interior ceiling
area, which causes condensation, puts our first floor mechanical
units under stress. Revision to
ceilings throughout common area must include proper support for
structural loading under stress of
wind events and include closing any air gaps, and providing
insulation above our suspended ceilings.
.
MANAGER’S REPORT
Month of November/December 2006
o Entrance lanterns damaged by Hurricane Wilma were
replaced at lobby 1 & 3. A matching hanging
light was replaced at lobby 2.
o Elevator doors and walls are being painted. New
signage identifying elevators has been ordered.
o Outdoor holiday lights are up and sparkling.
o 10 new grocery carts have been ordered for use by the owners
only.
o We are attempting to change the employee health plan from United
Health care to Vista Health Care
on January 1. If we are approved, the rate will be $12,800 less
than United Healthcare.
o A letter has been sent to Otis Elevator as a follow up to a phone
call to them yesterday. We are
requesting the following:
o Installation of stainless steel interior doors
for elevators E/F. G/H, and N/P.
o Additional elevator pads as per
contract.
o A
better system to hang the pads so they stay
up.
o
A credit for interior notice
boards
o
The A/C door project is 65%
complete.
o Vegetation on the beach is being cleaned up of
weeds.
o
Because Plaza East does not have a
service elevator, the new elevators are taking a beating by
contractor that have no respect for the property. Just yesterday a
contractor, J/K Kitchens, was
evicted from the property for trashing the common areas and cursing
at a resident. Some system must
be implemented to protect Plaza East from the dirt and destruction
caused by these contractors.
o Recommend spending $1,200 (labor) to tile
Managers Apartment, using existing tile in stock, motion
by President, Seconded by Packard, all voted
Aye.
o
Manager’s Otis Letter
As per our conversation on December 5t', the
following items need to be addressed promptly:
1. We still do not have the stainless steel door on E/F, G/H, and
-N/P, this was supposed to be
done a month ago.
2. We need elevator pads for all the elevators as provided in
contract. One set is not enough.
3. The current method of hanging the pads is unacceptable. They
continue to
fall down if someone or something rubs against them.
4. A credit for the notice boards inside the elevators. We have
opted to install them outside the
elevators and will do this project ourselves.
My understanding is that our modernization of C/D, J/K, and L/M is
going very well, but I would
like a more concise completion date than "maybe before Christmas or
after the first of the year".
Mike Morgan, Manager December 6, 2006
POORE PRESENTATION (as
per Board request and Vote of October 25, 2006
o Jeanne Poore
presented her Hurricane Wilma damage claim to middle bedroom
wall.
o Plaza East
presented its exhibits refuting claim by Poore, damage to wall was
by workers
removing mirrors, mastic attachment of mirror left gaping holes in
wall, requiring either
wall replacement or massive patching. Invoice was dated May 24,
2006 workers on that day
in 2A only spent a total of 3 hours labor time, confirmed by
contractor sign-in logs.
o Board Discussion
then Motion made to John Toklucu offer Jeanne Poore $1,200 less
the
$675 already paid, letter will be sent by Manager to Mrs. Poore as
offer to settle. Motion
seconded by Chuck Packard, all voted Aye
SCREENING
COMMITTEE
Jerry Marcial
reported on screening as follows:
PHB sold by Bruce and Renee Bell to Andrea Cardinalli for $550,000,
unfurnished. Richard Loarie made a
motion, seconded by Ismet Baker to approve the screening report.
All voted aye.
CORRESPONDENCE
We
received letters from:
o DBPR complaints by
Robert Buehler (budgeting of Insurance and adding two
cameras)
DBPR response by President in detail, demand by Goodwin of DBPR for
Monday
submission after Thanksgiving caused President to use Thanksgiving
Vacation time to
research 10 years of records for response. This issue could have
been addressed using
Buehler’s own time by investigating Plaza East records.
Buehler chose unilaterally use
others time, for which there is a cost, and passed on to him in the
amount of $2,400.
o Haykov 16N request for records, letter sent asking him
to make an appointment with
manager for record examination viewing.
o Mr. & Mrs. Bork unit10K letter sent concerning
unlicensed contracting and failure to secure
building permits, no answer received.
o Don Galczak unit 12A, operating & reserve budget,
responded to with three pages
documenting reserves, for any item which expenses or replacement
cost exceeding $10,000.
o Jeannette Shampain Unit 14N, interruption of last board
meeting by guest, letter sent
recommending her guests use lobby elevator for normal egress and
not exit stairs.
o DBPR informed us of two Wechsler complaints; (1)
addition to flue vent at pool, and (2)
elevator cabs being improvements. Neither are improvements.
o New Business – Handicap parking availability was
brought up by Marion Packard, stating
that there do not appear to be enough handicap spaces near the
lobby doors. There are 4
lower garage handicap parking spaces, upper garage 2 handicap
spaces and 1 exterior. Mike
Morgan will investigate and report back any possible additions near
lobby doors.
Motion made for Adjournment,
seconded, all voted Aye, meeting adjourned at 9:40 pm.
Respectfully submitted,
Richard Loarie,
Recording Secretary (in absence of Helene
Pasternak)