PLAZA EAST ASSOCIATION
MINUTES OF MEETING OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS
March 29, 2006
Mr. Richard Loarie,
President called to order a duly constituted meeting of the Plaza
East Board of Directors on Tuesday, March 29, 2006 at 7:30 p.m. in
the Recreation Room.
Present were: Ismet Baker, James Brady, Richard Loarie, Terry
Marcum, Charles Packard, Allen Pell DiAnne Shumard, Tim Smith, Alex
Soufrine and John Toklucu. Also present Willy Lopez, Manager and
Helene Pasternak, Secretary. A quorum was established.
Absent: Rafick Henein
APPROVAL
OF MINUTES
DiAnne Shumard made a
motion, seconded by John Toklucu to approve the minutes of the
Board Meeting of February 28, 2006 and the Special Meeting of the
Board of Directors held March 22, 2006. All approved.
TREASURER’S
REPORT
$5,260.00 was
transferred from the Reserve Fund to Operating to pay All Ready
Chute who installed 10 new trash chute doors. The complete
Treasurer’s Report is attached.
PRESIDENT’S
REPORT
Owners have a right to
speak at all regular Board meetings under Florida Statute
718.
Mr. Loarie has asked the office to obtain current copies of Florida
Statute 718 for all Board members.
Our Accountant, Ted Perella, and our Attorney, Rendell Roger, have
advised that we may use the excess funds from the 2005 Annual
Budget to offset our costs from Hurricane Wilma.
We may now declare common area shutters an emergency. The history
of the vote on the hurricane shutters was at the Annual
Owner’s Meeting in February the initial proxy failed to pass.
The meeting, reconvened for March, which was approved by the Owners
at the Annual Meeting did pass and an assessment of $250,000. was
levied to be paid in two payments.
However, since we received a letter dated March 13, 2006 of
“Notice of Non-Renewal” addressed to Mr. Jeff Samas
(Plaza East’s Insurance Broker) from the Florida Intracoastal
Underwriters stating that due to non-compliance to current building
codes, we may anticipate a possible substantial increase in
insurance costs. Quoting from this letter as follows:
“Regardless of the amount of wind capacity we have after June
1st, that capacity will be
allocated to those accounts that are best suited to survive the
predicted increase in hurricane activity. Those associations that
have taken proactive steps to protect their property through
installation of hurricane shutters or impact glas, along with a
well maintained roof, will be in a more advantageous position to
secure the limited amount of wind capacity that will be
available.”
Since Plaza East was not pro-active in taking steps to protect the
property through the installation of hurricane shutters or impact
glass, we may have to purchase our insurance from Citizens
Insurance at a highly increased cost. Mr. Loarie recommends that
let stand the shutter assessment as per the Board vote of March 22,
2006 from Shutter Tech, and have assessment commence in 30 days on
April 29 and be divided into two payments.
Mr. Loarie would like to change our documents to mandate all owners
must purchase hurricane shutters or high impact windows.
We had a question and challenge by Bob Buehler (7N) or the new
awning size which is the same height and pitch of roof but 12 feet
longer than the previous awning.
History: In 2000 (reference Minutes
of Meeting March 30, 2000) our awning was replaced
with an upgrade of materials from galvanized iron to aluminum when
Mr. Buehler was on the Board. The upgrade of materials was not
challenged by him nor was a 75% vote required. The original awning
as per Developer’s original approved plan is the same as the
new awning we are now installing. A letter will be sent to Mr.
Buehler.
Mr. Loarie would like to see as a top priority of establishing a
request from the membership to change our voting from its current
75% of all owners to 75% of those voting, or something along these
lines. Ismet Baker and DiAnne Shumard are working on this
issue.
Committee Sign-Up sheets are available outside of the office for
those interested in participating in a pro-active manner to improve
our community and neighborhood.
MANAGER’S
REPORT
Willy Lopez reported
that garbage chute doors have been replaced in 10 units. Any owners
needing new chute doors should contact the office.
Willy and Ismet Baker met with two public adjusters. One of them,
Bob Moskowitz, said he did not believe that our Wilma damage
exceeded our insurance deductible. The said he would represent us
subject to a report of a forensic engineer. Such report would cost
from $15,000 to $25,000.00.
American Glass is continuing to replace all glass damaged by
Hurricane Wilma. There are 16 units where the glass can not be
replaced because new window frames are required. Approximate cost
of replacement is $100,000.00. There is not enough money from the
2005 operating surplus of $138,000 to pay for all of the Wilma
damage. A special assessment will be required for the excess. Tim
Smith will review the repair costs and advise the Board with a
final recommendation.
Circle Generator came to make recommendations concerning our
emergency generator. To make our current generator self-cooling,
the cost would be $12,000. to $17,000. A new self-cooling generator
would cost from $60,000-$70,000. Our generator is 38 years old and
part replacements are becoming a problem. Willy will try to get
other opinions and estimates for the Board so that they can make a
decision.
EST (GE) continues to work on the fire alarm system. This week they
are working in the G & H stacks. The elevator project work
continues with Gammon working on the electrical in the J-K and C-D
towers.
The Manager’s complete report is attached.
NEW
WINDOW
Mr. Troutman (6C) asks
the Board for approval to replace his kitchen window upon
submitting engineering drawings and permits. Terry Marcum made a
motion seconded by John Toklucu to allow Apartment 6C to replace
their kitchen window. All Approved.
SCREENING
COMMITTEE
Jerry Marcial,
Chairperson, advised the committee has interviewed Roberto
Parcella, new owner of apartment 11M. The purchased price was
$590,000.00 unfurnished. A motion was made by Tim Smith, seconded
by Ismet Baker to approve Mr. Marcial’s report. All voted
aye.
HURRICANE
SHUTTERS-COMMON AREAS
Terry Marcum made a
motion, seconded by Alex Soufrine to change the dates of the
Hurricane Shutter Assessment payable in 2 equal installments on May
1, 2006 and July 1, 2006.
All voted aye.
Tim Smith made a motion, seconded by John Toklucu to hire Shutter
Tech to install the hurricane shutters.
All voted aye except for James Brady and Alex Soufrine who voted
nay.
HURRICANE ASSESSMENT
There was a discussion
concerning hurricane damage and costs. Mr. Lopez and Mr. Smith
think the cost is between $400-600,000.
A motion was made to assess for Hurricane Damage at a meeting on
April 18, 2006. Motion was made by Richard Loarie and seconded by
John Toklucu. All voted aye.
John Toklucu made a motion, seconded by Richard Loarie to adjourn
the meeting at 9:10 PM. All approved.
Respectfully submitted,
Helene Pasternak
Recording Secretary